We had a wonderful experience tonight at The Mill. We started out with a cocktail at the bar. Dusty makes a great old fashioned and we had a nice chat reminiscing about growing up on farms in DC. We proceeded to the dining room and were greeted promptly by the host and then our server Moi. Moi provided great service throughout our dinner, paced things perfectly, and made excellent recommendations. To start, at Moi's recommendation, I had the whitefish chowder - chowda!! It was a highlight: rich, creamy, and full of whitefish, potato chunks, corn, and an herb or two (thyme, perhaps?) Next up, the king cut prime rib, rare, with buttered red potatoes, creamy horseradish and au jus. Note: I ordered the king cut specifically to have leftovers, for who can eat that much meat in one sitting? Not me. It was a glorious hunk of meat, everything I look for in a PR: fragrant, flavorful, well-marbled meaty deliciousness (I know, I can be so eloquent.) I PR and this was like a valentine to me. The au jus and creamy horseradish were just right as accompaniments. Lastly (and certainly not leastly): dessert in the form of a Brandy Alexander - shared between my two dining companions and myself. It was so thick the straws collapsed. We resorted to spoons. It was the perfect end to a delicious meal. We will be back!
Overview
If you're craving a cozy dining experience that combines great food with a welcoming atmosphere, look no further than The Mill Supper Club in Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin. Located at 4128 WI-42 WI-57, this beloved spot has earned a reputation for offering an exceptional dining experience that celebrates the charm of Door County.
At The Mill Supper Club, the menu is filled with a variety of dishes that bring comfort and flavor to every bite. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty steak, fresh seafood, or a light salad, thereβs something for everyone. Their specialties include tender cuts of prime rib, which are always cooked to perfection, and their famous fish fry, a local favorite that keeps guests coming back week after week.
The dining room is warm and inviting, with rustic dΓ©cor that perfectly complements the traditional supper club vibe. Itβs the kind of place where you can kick back, enjoy good conversation, and savor your meal without feeling rushed. The service is top-notch, with friendly staff who go above and beyond to make your visit feel special. Itβs easy to see why The Mill Supper Club is a go-to spot for both locals and visitors to Sturgeon Bay.
A big draw to this restaurant is its location. Nestled on the scenic WI-42 WI-57 highway, itβs an easy stop whether you're making your way through Door County or just coming from a day of sightseeing. Its proximity to local attractions makes it a great choice for a post-adventure meal, and with ample parking available, itβs convenient for everyone.
The drink menu at The Mill Supper Club is equally impressive, with a selection of craft beers, wines, and cocktails that pair perfectly with any meal. The classic old-fashioned is a popular choice, a refreshing nod to the restaurantβs supper club roots. For those looking for a more modern twist, their creative cocktails offer something new for every palate.
What sets The Mill Supper Club apart from other dining spots is its commitment to quality and consistency. The restaurant takes pride in using fresh, locally sourced ingredients, ensuring every dish is not only delicious but also made with care. Whether youβre enjoying their signature steaks or diving into one of their delicious desserts, you can trust that every bite is crafted with attention to detail.
For those planning a special occasion, The Mill Supper Club is an excellent choice. With its warm ambiance, excellent service, and fantastic food, itβs perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, or any celebration. They also offer catering services for private events, ensuring your next gathering is a memorable one.
Many patrons rave about the intimate yet lively atmosphere, making it a great place to relax with family or enjoy a night out with friends. The restaurantβs long-standing presence in the community speaks volumes about its dedication to serving great food and creating a welcoming space for all.
As one of the most renowned spots in the area, The Mill Supper Club continues to delight guests with its exceptional food, inviting atmosphere, and unmatched service. Whether you're a local or just visiting, itβs a must-try dining destination in Sturgeon Bay.
Good to know
Service options
β Takeaway β Dine-inHighlights
β Fast service β Great beer selection β Great cocktails β Great dessert β Great wine list β Serves local specialtyPopular for
β Dinner β Solo diningAccessibility
β Wheelchair-accessible car park β Wheelchair-accessible entrance β Wheelchair-accessible seating β Wheelchair-accessible toiletOfferings
β Alcohol β All you can eat β Beer β Cocktails β Coffee β Comfort food β Happy-hour drinks β Happy-hour food β Salad bar β Spirits β WineDining options
β Dinner β Dessert β Seating β Table serviceAmenities
β Bar on site β Toilet β Wi-Fi β Wi-FiAtmosphere
β Casual β Cosy β HistoricCrowd
β Family friendly β Groups β TouristsPayments
β Credit cards β Debit cards β NFC mobile payments β Credit cardsChildren
β Good for kids β Has changing table(s) β High chairs β Kids' menuParking
β Free of charge street parking β Free parking lot β ParkingPhotos
Location
Reviews
Food was decent, not amazing. No real complaints - I've had worse and I've had better. Two friends ordered steaks the same doneness, one was perfect but the other was overcooked. The atmosphere wasn't really like a supper club -it didn't feel cozy like most do. Clean and normal for a restaurant but did not have the "supper club" vibe. Service was friendly and fast!
First time dining here, but certainly not the last. Food was top notch. The bartenders and our server were amazing. The bar has a nostalgic feel to it, however the dining area is very clean and modern. If I had to give any constructive feedback it would be to get sharper steak knives, otherwise everything else was amazing!
Can't beat the Thursday surf and turff. Prime rib and perch, salad bar and a ice cold Polka king. Updated to a 5 star. Been going there close 2 15 years now. Always good! The family style chicken is awesome. Great owners and staff.