The Mill Supper Club Menu
FOOD - Appetizers
Cheese Curds
Yellow Curds Lightly Breaded and Fried Served with House Made Ranch
US$12.00
Currywurst Poutine
Shoestring Cut Fries, topped with Curds, Fried Wurst, and Curry Gravy
US$16.00
Deviled Eggs
US$8.00
Giant Pretzel
Served with Pub Mustard and House Made Beer Cheese Sauce
US$18.00
Onion Petals
Beer Battered and Fried to Golden Brown Served with House Spicy Aioli
US$10.00
Potato Pancakes
US$12.00
Reuben Wonton Bites
Wonton Wrapped Corn Beef, Cabbage, and Swiss Cheese Served with House Made Spicy Aioli
US$14.00
FOOD - Soup
Cup Soup
US$5.00
Bowl Soup
US$8.00
FOOD - Salads
Caesar Salad
US$13.00
Side Caesar Salad
US$9.00
Kids Salad Bar
US$8.00
FOOD - Sides/Extras
Side Baked Potato
US$5.00
Side Loaded Baked
US$6.00
Side Risotto
US$7.00
Side VOD
US$5.00
Side Aspargus
US$6.00
Side Buttered Baby Reds
US$5.00
Side German Baby Reds
US$6.00
Side American Potato Salad (Friday Only)
US$5.00
Side Spatzel
US$5.00
Side Sweet & Sour Red Cabbage
US$4.00
Side Apple Sauce
US$4.00
Side Coleslaw
US$4.00
Side Beer Cheese Sauce
US$2.00
Side Lemon Caper Sauce
US$4.00
Side Jager Sauce
US$4.00
Side Alfredo Sauce
US$2.00
Side Pub Mustard
US$2.00
Side Ranch
US$0.75
ExtraTartar
US$0.75
Extra Sour Cream
US$0.75
Side Creme Friche
US$1.00
Side Mayo
US$0.75
Quart Slaw
US$12.00
Quart Potato Salad
US$14.00
FOOD - Entrees
Filet Mignon
8oz Certified Angus Beef Tenderloin Grilled to Order
$
Ribeye
14oz Choice Angus Ribeye Grilled to Order
$
Shrimp Dinner
8 Shrimp Hand Breaded and Deep Fried to a Golden Brown or Sautéed in Garlic and Butter
$
Walleye (1)
$
Walleye (2)
Two Filets Lightly Breaded Served Deep Fried or Pan Fried
$
Perch (3)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
$
Perch (5)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
$
Whitefish Dinner
Served Broiled with Lemon Caper Butter, Cajun Style, or Deep Fried
$
Grilled Salmon
8oz Grilled Salmon Filet in a Seasoned Garlic Herb Butter
$
Mill Scallops
Sautéed Scallops served over Seasonal Asparagus with Bavarian Mustard Sauce and Tomato Tarragon
$
FOOD - German/Pastas
Chicken Jaeger Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Chicken topped with Onion Mushroom Sour Cream Gravy Served with your choice of Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
Wiener Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Pork topped with Lemon Caper Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
Half Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
$
Full Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
$
Linguine Carbonara
$
Alfredo Pasta
Wide Pasta tossed with House Made Alfredo
$
Mushroom Ravioli
Tender Ravioli Stuffed with Portabella and Crimini Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, and Garlic in Our House Made Alfredo Garnished with Cherry Tomato and Grilled Asparagus
$
Cajun Shrimp Pasta
$
FOOD - Sandwiches
Hamburger
Third Pound Burger topped with Fresh Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
US$15.00
Schnitzel Sandwich
Choice of Pork or Chicken Schnitzel topped with Swiss Cheese, Braised Red Cabbage, and Bavarian Mustard on a Pretzel Bun
US$15.00
Chicken BLT
Choice of 6oz Grilled or Crispy Chicken Breast topped with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo
US$16.00
BBQ Bacon Blue Burger
Third Pound Burger topped with melted Blue Cheese Crumbles, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
US$17.00
FOOD - Kids
Boneless Wings
$
Kids Buttered Noodles
$
Kids Fried Shrimp (3)
$
Macaroni & Cheese
$
FOOD - Desserts
Verry Berry Cheese Cake
US$9.00
Peppermint Patty Torte
US$8.00
Kids Ice Cream Sundae
US$5.00
Appetizers
Cheese Curds
Yellow Curds Lightly Breaded and Fried Served with House Made Ranch
US$12.00
Currywurst Poutine
Shoestring Cut Fries, topped with Curds, Fried Wurst, and Curry Gravy
US$16.00
Deviled Eggs
US$8.00
Giant Pretzel
Served with Pub Mustard and House Made Beer Cheese Sauce
US$18.00
Onion Petals
Beer Battered and Fried to Golden Brown Served with House Spicy Aioli
US$10.00
Potato Pancakes
US$12.00
Reuben Wonton Bites
Wonton Wrapped Corn Beef, Cabbage, and Swiss Cheese Served with House Made Spicy Aioli
US$14.00
Soup
Cup Soup
US$5.00
Bowl Soup
US$8.00
Salads
Caesar Salad
US$13.00
Side Caesar Salad
US$9.00
Kids Salad Bar
US$8.00
Sides/Extras
Side Baked Potato
US$5.00
Side Loaded Baked
US$6.00
Side Risotto
US$7.00
Side VOD
US$5.00
Side Aspargus
US$6.00
Side Buttered Baby Reds
US$5.00
Side German Baby Reds
US$6.00
Side American Potato Salad (Friday Only)
US$5.00
Side Spatzel
US$5.00
Side Sweet & Sour Red Cabbage
US$4.00
Side Apple Sauce
US$4.00
Side Coleslaw
US$4.00
Side Beer Cheese Sauce
US$2.00
Side Lemon Caper Sauce
US$4.00
Side Jager Sauce
US$4.00
Side Alfredo Sauce
US$2.00
Side Pub Mustard
US$2.00
Side Ranch
US$0.75
ExtraTartar
US$0.75
Extra Sour Cream
US$0.75
Side Creme Friche
US$1.00
Side Mayo
US$0.75
Quart Slaw
US$12.00
Quart Potato Salad
US$14.00
Entrees
Filet Mignon
8oz Certified Angus Beef Tenderloin Grilled to Order
$
Ribeye
14oz Choice Angus Ribeye Grilled to Order
$
Shrimp Dinner
8 Shrimp Hand Breaded and Deep Fried to a Golden Brown or Sautéed in Garlic and Butter
$
Walleye (1)
$
Walleye (2)
Two Filets Lightly Breaded Served Deep Fried or Pan Fried
$
Perch (3)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
$
Perch (5)
Lake Perch Served Deep or Pan Fried
$
Whitefish Dinner
Served Broiled with Lemon Caper Butter, Cajun Style, or Deep Fried
$
Grilled Salmon
8oz Grilled Salmon Filet in a Seasoned Garlic Herb Butter
$
Mill Scallops
Sautéed Scallops served over Seasonal Asparagus with Bavarian Mustard Sauce and Tomato Tarragon
$
German/Pastas
Chicken Jaeger Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Chicken topped with Onion Mushroom Sour Cream Gravy Served with your choice of Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
Wiener Schnitzel
Hand Breaded Fried Pork topped with Lemon Caper Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
Half Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
$
Full Rack BBQ Baby Back Ribs
$
Linguine Carbonara
$
Alfredo Pasta
Wide Pasta tossed with House Made Alfredo
$
Mushroom Ravioli
Tender Ravioli Stuffed with Portabella and Crimini Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, and Garlic in Our House Made Alfredo Garnished with Cherry Tomato and Grilled Asparagus
$
Cajun Shrimp Pasta
$
Sandwiches
Hamburger
Third Pound Burger topped with Fresh Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
US$15.00
Schnitzel Sandwich
Choice of Pork or Chicken Schnitzel topped with Swiss Cheese, Braised Red Cabbage, and Bavarian Mustard on a Pretzel Bun
US$15.00
Chicken BLT
Choice of 6oz Grilled or Crispy Chicken Breast topped with Applewood Smoked Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, and Mayo
US$16.00
BBQ Bacon Blue Burger
Third Pound Burger topped with melted Blue Cheese Crumbles, Applewood Smoked Bacon, Tomato, Lettuce, and Onion
US$17.00
Kids
Boneless Wings
$
Kids Buttered Noodles
$
Kids Fried Shrimp (3)
$
Macaroni & Cheese
$
Desserts
Verry Berry Cheese Cake
US$9.00
Peppermint Patty Torte
US$8.00
Kids Ice Cream Sundae
US$5.00
Thursday & Sunday Special - Thursday & Sunday Special
TOGO 4 Piece Chicken Dinner
4-Piece Mill Original Baked Chicken or Broasted Chicken with Whipped Potatoes, Dressing, Gravy, Cranberries, Coleslaw, and a Fresh Roll
US$18.00
Thursday & Sunday Special
TOGO 4 Piece Chicken Dinner
4-Piece Mill Original Baked Chicken or Broasted Chicken with Whipped Potatoes, Dressing, Gravy, Cranberries, Coleslaw, and a Fresh Roll
US$18.00
Wednesday Special - Wednesday Special
Schwenkbraten
14oz Center Cut Broasted Pork Chop with House Made Apple Chutney
$
Wednesday Special
Schwenkbraten
14oz Center Cut Broasted Pork Chop with House Made Apple Chutney
$
Friday Special - Friday Specials
Perch Special
$
Walleye Special
$
Shrimp Beer Battered Special
$
Deep Fried White Fish Special
$
Scallops Special
$
Cod Beer Battered Special
$
Seafood Platter
$
Friday Specials
Perch Special
$
Walleye Special
$
Shrimp Beer Battered Special
$
Deep Fried White Fish Special
$
Scallops Special
$
Cod Beer Battered Special
$
Seafood Platter
$
Saturday Special - Saturday Special
Prime Rib
Slow Roasted and served with choice of Side, Soup or Salad, and Fresh Rolls
$
Saturday Special
Prime Rib
Slow Roasted and served with choice of Side, Soup or Salad, and Fresh Rolls
$
Tuesday Special - Tuesday Special
Meatball Stroganoff
Thin Beef Roll Stuffed with Onion, Pickle, and Dijon Mustard Wrapped with Bacon and topped with Bavarian Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
Tuesday Special
Meatball Stroganoff
Thin Beef Roll Stuffed with Onion, Pickle, and Dijon Mustard Wrapped with Bacon and topped with Bavarian Sauce Served with your choice or Buttered Baby Red Potatoes or Spätzle Kaese, and Sweet and Sour Red Cabbage
$
If you’re browsing The Mill Supper Club Menu, get ready for the kind of hearty, no-frills dishes that make Wisconsin supper clubs so special. Tucked along 4128 WI-42 WI-57 in Sturgeon Bay, this spot leans into tradition in the best way possible. The menu reads like a greatest hits list of comfort food classics - think tender prime rib, perfectly broiled steaks, and golden fried perch that practically demands a squeeze of lemon.
What really stands out, though, is how everything feels thoughtfully put together. You’ll find crisp salads, warm rolls, and rich, house-made soups that set the tone before the main plate even arrives. Then there are the sides - creamy potatoes, seasonal vegetables, and those small extras that make the meal feel complete. Whether you’re in the mood for a classic Old Fashioned alongside your steak or craving a Friday night fish fry experience, this menu captures that relaxed, come-hungry-and-stay-awhile supper club vibe without trying too hard.